Condorcet versus Borda, a response to: Comment on “A New Method to Obtain a Consensus Ranking of a Region’s Vintages’ Quality”
نویسندگان
چکیده
In response to the work of Borges et al. (2012), Hulkower (2012) poses questions regarding the relative merits of the Condorcet and the Borda methods; a topic which has been taking place in socio-political studies for a very long time. While both approaches have their supporters and their detractors (Young, 1988; Risse, 2005; Saari, 2006), below we present the reasons for choosing Condorcet’s method to obtain a consensus ranking of a region’s vintage quality (Borges et al., 2012).
منابع مشابه
Fractal-wavelet-fusion-based re-ranking of joint roughness coefficients
Nowadays, Barton’s Joint Roughness Coefficients (JRC) are widely used as the index for roughness and as a challenging fracture property. When JRC ranking is the goal, deriving JRC from different fractal/wavelet procedures can be conflicting. Complexity increases when various rankings outcome from different calculation methods. Therefore, using Barton’s JRC, we cannot make a decision based on th...
متن کاملبهبود روش تصمیمگیری گروهی بوردا با کمک محاسبات نرم
Borda count is a well-known social choice method, and is frequently used for group decision making problems. However it does not consider the optimism/pessimism view of the director, which has a great effect on the group decisions. Therefore in the present study, we extend the Borda method by using the Ordered Weighted Averaging (OWA) operator to consider the risk attitudinal characteristics....
متن کاملCombinación de clusterizadores difusos mediante voto posicional para clustering robusto de documentos
The combination of multiple clustering processes provides a means for building robust document clustering systems. This work focuses on the consolidation of fuzzy clusterings, proposing two consensus functions for soft cluster ensembles based on the Borda and Condorcet positional voting strategies. Experiments conducted on two document corpora reveal that the proposed soft consensus functions a...
متن کاملCondorcet and borda count fusion method for ligand-based virtual screening
BACKGROUND It is known that any individual similarity measure will not always give the best recall of active molecule structure for all types of activity classes. Recently, the effectiveness of ligand-based virtual screening approaches can be enhanced by using data fusion. Data fusion can be implemented using two different approaches: group fusion and similarity fusion. Similarity fusion involv...
متن کاملبهکارگیری روشهای تصمیمگیری چندشاخصه برای رتبهبندی اقتصادی مناطق شهری جهت احداث مراکز تجاری (مورد مطالعه: شهر تهران)
One of the most important effective factors on more profit and success in financial and commercial activities is the place and geographical location of establishing that activity In order to achieve this important issue, we require exact locational information needing much cost and time. Thus, economic ranking of urban areas can make economic status of urban areas clear for managers. This resea...
متن کامل